Jandek.
In the world of white-boy music-geek fandom, there is none higher. No single name evokes more ebullient outbursts of nerdy pride. He is a living rock myth, a folk hero for losers, an icon for individualism. You know... or some shit.
I have admittedly contributed to the cult of Jandek by simply being a fan of his carefully cultivated public persona. I have also struggled with my ideas about the man and his music as I have found much of his work (and I have a shitload of it) to be unlistenable.
In the early 90s I was roommates with Tom Carter, then Mike Gunn guitarist, now avant-garde sensation in his own right. Tom worked in the local underground record shop and thus had a huge selection of records that I willingly and thankfully plundered daily. He was the guy to introduce me to the music of Jandek. I found the shattered and disemboweled blues-ish horror show to be oddly fascinating in a Cramps play an asylum sort of way. I also dug that whoever Jandek really was was something very carefully guarded. I also liked that there were bits of information that would occasionally surface that shed some light on who the reclusive and prolific artist really was.
Back then nobody really knew about the guy save for record dorks like Tom. This didn't make Jandek cool, it made him sort of warmly pathetic. He seemed to do whatever he was doing because he was compelled to, not because he had some master plan to be the king of hipster dorkdom.
Over time of course thing changed for our hometown hero. Spin magazine hit the guy up in an article. Texas Monthly tracked him down. Some folks put together a documentary about the man which was much more interesting than perhaps the man himself. And in the process they exposed the beauty of Jandek. He began to function as a mirror to the dreams of music dweebs.
It wasn't long before you-know-who made a now legendary appearance (unannounced, naturally) at an outsider-ish music festival in Scotland. With the cat more or less out of the bag, suddenly the guy was out and about. It became feasible to read about him bagging Paris, or knocking up Sarah Palin's kid, or what have you. He was becoming a little too... exposed.
And this was the point at which the rift began to open in his ocean-wide reputation as a reclusive cipher.
Enter Sunday afternoon.
Jandek shows now being a dime a dozen, it was only a matter of time before he headlined his own local performance.
But not to be outdone by himself it had to be something special.
So what does the sepulchral lord of darkness and shadow do? What does the undisputed master of hiding and mystery do?
He plays a day show, at a pub, to a cheering, dancing, adoring audience.
And best of all...
He plays funk.
Funk.
With slap bass and groovy drumming.
He plays a 90 minute freeform funk jam. And he motherfucking raps.
And no, it isn't cool in an ironic sort of way, and no it isn't transcendent in a do what you want and fuck who doesn't get it kind of way.
Nahh, it's none of that.
What Jandek does is erase every last shred of mystique and curiosity and wonder and appeal and simply reduces himself to an indulgent dupe who has consumed barrels of his own kool-aid and has come out the other side as the single most fervent adherent to the cult of himself.
Not cool. Not clever. Not good. Not worth it.
Just unabashed and unadulterated garbage. Street corner busking with a pitiful withered husk of a man begging for your love. He emerged from his self-made cocoon, shed his parchment-like skin, and burst forth a newly minted reflection of whatever idiotic dreams everyone but himself had made of him.
The well has been poisoned.
The drinks are watered down.
His naked majesty, the grand marshal, the overseer of nightmares, paraded before us, in the bright light of spring, and exposed to be nothing more than what he really ever was...
A man.
Too bad. I liked our idea of him better.
Monday, April 6, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
27 Comments:
Nice. I skipped out as I saw a phenomenal Jandek show at SXSW two years ago and figured this just couldn't top that experience. Plus, I figured it'd be crowded too.
Anyhow, maybe it ruins the mystique but I think it's kind of cool for Jandek to actually be able to kick back and have fun. Not that I can judge the show having not been there but just in principle i don't have any issues with it. But then again while I really was blown away by the show I did see I'm not one to pee myself if I see Jandek or any other rock star on the street.
I don't want the guy to never have fun or anything. Sure, it might be interesting to see him express joy openly, but that doesn't mean I could find that shitpile to be anything even vaguely approaching relevant. That performance was pure wasteful farce and yet we all enjoy what we enjoy. I wasn't there, and while from the video alone I am glad I wasn't there, I wouldn't try to take the fun away from anyone who was into it. But that sentiment is also irrelevant. What is relevant is our opinions on the "art." My opinion is that here is a man who is no longer interesting, and worse, is now no longer in on the joke. That's okay, it's not actually important. We have actual lives, actual problems, actual things to worry about. I am clearly prone to regard the train-wreck of cultural disaster as interesting, and in that I thank Jandek. And now, I bid him (in your words) adieu.
Thanks for stopping by, and thanks for commenting. Anytime you want to post anything on anything, please do. You are an honored guest. Now, buzz off.
Great review. regardless of the show. The magic trick is almost always more interesting than the explanation of how the magician does it. And the magician him/herself? What do you imagine they are like?
To me Jandek is the guy on the opposite end of the coin from Jeff Koons. The art without the artist is nothing, except in this case the artist was nothing. Instead of selling everyday objects for absurd amounts, Jandek was selling a strange version of nothing for hardly anything if anything at all (a few dollars maybe). Any satisfaction or personal accomplishments or tragedies he might have experienced were only the ones we could make up in our heads.
I always thought it best to never listen to any of him music. Worked better. So I have never heard a single note he has written.
Now he is cashing in. Good for him, i'm sure i would too. I hope he's getting laid and doing lots of drugs. He should change his name too. Maybe something like David Blaine or something. I know nothing about the man or his music. I like it like that.
but seriously, i loved that piece of writing John. Very clear, historic, personal, character development, all the good stuff. thanks.
You are mercifully generous. Thanks.
I liked the part about parading the monster through the streets in broad daylight. As for Jandek and his art? At least someone is making a living off of their crap.
I don't think he makes a living off of the funk, I think he's an investment banker... Wait, maybe this is his bread and butter now! He's sold out in order to cash in! Next stop, a tour with Taylor Swift!
i feel like there is a very important part of the show that is worth mentioning and hillarious. the act was not rehearsed. jandek did not even know these musicians.
and, why shouldn't the guy be able to do whatever the fuck he wants? i really doubt he was begging for our love at that show. it was a party. very lighthearted. to poo poo on it is shameful. no one knows what jandeks intentions are. so he's chosen to do his music, whatever form it may be, in whatever fashion he wants.
and it's refreshing to see someone up there having fun and not being a self-important recluse.
it was a happening, a performance piece. by his own creation. dyi all the way. there is something to be said for that.
besides his playing was skillfully bad and his funny talking was good!
it was what it was.
Who said he can't do what he wants? There's nothing shameful about ragging on any show, mine included. What, did you get a lobotomy before setting out to get into music? All of nothing is good. That's how we get through the day, we make decisions. Our opinions change, mine always do, but we are entitled to them. I thought it was ridiculous trash. Big deal. You loved it. Great. We're both right because it's up to us to write the narrative, eh? I'm no Jandek hater either, I don't see him without merit, I simply thought the show (from what I've seen indirectly) was shit. What isn't what "it is"? That doesn't even need mentioning if you think about it. I thought the music from the video was terrible. I found it to be throw-away white-boy funk nonsense. I'll tell you what his majesty doesn't need, he doesn't need you to defend him anymore than he needs me to tear him down. He's a big boy, he can take it.
You won't believe this part, but thank you for commenting. Wanna post? Seriously. At the end of the day, I am honestly glad you love music, whoever you are. It's a far cry better than not being into it. That to me is murder.
The only thing pathetic about that video are the droves of dumb asses (friends included) dancing around for the 6 odd minutes of bullshit as if the joke hadn't worn off after ten seconds. And if that went on for a full set then, well...Rudz still serves those tasty burgers?
I'd still be very keen to meet the man. He was merely an idea to the Houston musicians I hung out with in the early nineties --what I mean is, we didn't sit around listening to his albums and thought perhaps they were hardly the point anyway. I put more thought into him after that documentary which you're right about. It is possibly more interesting than the source or at least it adds tactfully to the mystique. And, never is a Jandek track played for more than a few seconds in that documentary as I recall. I'd have to say I'm more interested in the man --I find him to be the true Corwood Industry product.
Ha! Go Mlee! :)
I posted my impression of the show elsewhere but thought it appropriate here also.
It was the musical equivalent of what I imagine seeing Andy Kaufman do stand up was like. I was disappointed to not hear the angular, atonal guitar playing and mumbled cryptic lyrics I was expecting but did find it entertaining in a DaDa kind of way for about 5 minutes.
The music itself I found horrendous as the Jandek playing on top of a funk rhythm section experiment did not do it for me as it apparently did for the rest of the crowd. However, I too doubt the crowd would have been as 'into' it if it were some wedding band laying down red hot chili pepper grooves from the late 80's which is what it sounded like.
But then again fun is in the eye/ear of the beholder. All in all worth 4 bucks and a few hours on a Sunday afternoon plus I got to eat chicken tenders and watch Jandek as planned.
I found it to be throw-away white-boy funk nonsense."
Is it still "white-boy" funk if one of the people in the band is black?
wow, mr. cramer, i think you took my comments personally. your blog wasn't shameful, nor is it shameful or wrong for you to post your opinion. however, in my opinion, it is shameful to poo poo on someone else's fun. i suppose when i read your review of the show, i thought it was almost trying to turn the show into what you thought it was, not what it really was or could have been, to anyone else, or even jandek himself. bottom line, you are not giving jandek enough credit. do you really think he doesn't know what he's up to? and honestly, i am not defending jandek, i am not even a fan of his nor do i own any of his records. but i live in houston, and i am surrounded by fans of his and have watched the dumb documentary and heard his stuff. i was just countering your idea of the show by saying, so what if he plays white boy funk? it was horrible. it was fun. it was nonsense. but i don't think that means jandek is an indulgent dupe who is now revealed and lame.
anyway good writing though, and good review! just, i disagree with your opinions. isn't that why you allow comments?
so you are crying because he did not do what you expected him to do. sho what? I am glad he shattered your bullshit illusions, and your bullshit preconcieved notions of what Jandek the man wants to do. I thought it was fuk as fuck and just another aspect of man who is very private and shares nothing of himself.
grow up.
"What Jandek does is erase every last shred of mystique and curiosity and wonder and appeal and simply reduces himself to an indulgent dupe who has consumed barrels of his own kool-aid and has come out the other side as the single most fervent adherent to the cult of himself."
Maybe what Jandek did was erase every last shred of mystique and curiosity and wonder and appeal YOU had left for him, and reduced you to a dupe who has consumed barrels of bad Jandek albums only to have the man himself expose one of the biggest inside jokes in music history.
and the show was only 4 bucks. I got what I paid for at least 2 times over.
The mystique and speculation about Jandek is why people are drawn to him. That's why it was cool to see him. The people with no expectations were the only ones who enjoyed the show.
I lost count of the number of photographers and digital recorders who were waiting for some mythic historical moment they could put up on youtube. It was as if you could see the blogosphere being bummed out in real-time, and sorry but it was fun.
Everybody who has a negative take on the show, all admit to having not gone. So what are you really saying? I haven't watched the youtube video but I'll go ahead and review it. It sucks. There is a showboating bass player straight out of the Arsenio Hall show, a boring drummer, and Jandek is rapping.
I'm not saying, I'm just saying, the show was another story. A weirdly awkward fun show.
the sad thing is john, you weren't even there. you are just a grumpy old man (methinks) sitting at home with your half-empty eye on the world desparately flinging poo at the young and the living. you don't have to reveal jandek, he's revealed himself, and he doesn't give a shit. he wouldn't play terrible funk music if he gave a shit about his ego. you need to relax, and how about actually attending the shows you review. so, you watched a lo-fi video of jandek's show on your computer monitor and listened with your tiny little computer speakers, and you now believe you have the power to bethrone him? no one i know ever referred to him as your majesty, except for you, which is lame. you only did that so you could tear him down! now you are at the butt of a joke that everyone gets but you.
Fuck Jandek and the detuned guitar he rode in on. Kilian is right. The only thing worse than the music are the adoring tards that payed money to see that trash. It's not clever, ironic, or artistic at all. I work my ass off at a job I hate, try to raise two little ones up to be decent, and try to fit in time to play music that I hope at least a few people enjoy whilst not getting paid a fuckin dime. Oh, and Mlee, I'm not a wordsmith by any means but your comment said zilch to me.
As you were...
As an objective third party who has no knowledge of the guy other than a ridiculous story about someone I know sleeping with Jandek and few conversations with John, I think it was/is total crap. The bass player and drummer played the same thing over and over while Jandek looked like he was trying to simulate playing with himself. He didn't do much at all, really. That, to me, is not even music. The crowd seemed to think it was the coolest shit ever because that's what the hip kids think, right? If it's your thing, great. I admittedly like some pretty bad music, but I like it autonomously.
First off, I appreciate all the comments, and I want to say sorry it took so long for them to get approved, I had to get home from work to do that!
I am surprised at the hostility towards me as if I have somehow wronged some of you. I readily admit I wasn't there, and yes reviewing a show I didn't attend is impossible. I reviewed a six minute video. Fair enough.
Attacking me because I'm too old is retarded, but I suppose you will argue that attacking the young crowd is equally retarded. Again, fair enough. And yes, Mlee, I welcome comments and am not trying to tear you or anyone else down whenever you do comment. I do think it's odd how you try to tell me what Jandek had in mind in your opinion in the same argument during which you tell me I basically am wrong with mine. Am I wrong in that observation? Should I claim you are too young and ignorant to understand the weakness of that show? I don't think that. Whoever had fun, that's wonderful. Really. No joke. Was I there? No. Do I enjoy live music? I do. Am I glad I wasn't at that one? Pretty much. Does this somehow mean I think I am better than you because I thought it was shit? No, because I don't.
The very preconceived notions I am being attacked for seem to come from some of these comments with regards to how I should have taken the video as if I must adhere to your (whoever "you" are) ideas of what fun is, or what art is, or what is relevant.
The review was a piece of criticism. I am not claiming absolute authority or claiming to be in Jandek's head. I am drawing conclusions and expressing opinions.
Whoever thinks I am not entitled to see the funk explosion as shit might consider growing up as well.
No, Mlee, I don't take your comments personally. I love them. This blog is useless to me without some participation other than mine.
I wrote a critique, I stand by it. i took my digs, nobody was really hurt, and we all live another day.
Still, that video was awful. Oh, and black bassist or not, that was the worst kind of white-boy rap.
Anyone want a guest post? To write about music, or whatever you like? Hit me up.
Mlee, how could anyone really know what any show "really was"? That's impossible. Of course I turned it into what I thought it was, so did you. So does everyone.
Why did your third comment suddenly seem so angry?
Just wondering.
In (late) response to some of the comments, I am that age, and I think those people are retards.
With this many comments and fires lit under asses, I think the butcher is now a hit. Congratulations.
I'm not really up to date on slang - what does "fuk as fuck" mean?
Hopefully you all see these posts back and forth as constructive debate and not personal attacks. Come to think of it, the attacks are fun too. Cramer, you're a douche and no one likes you. You in?
Back when Houston's music scene was evolving, age was never an issue. There were so many obstacles for scenesters to overcome that there was a sense of community. People had their music preferences, had their niche groups, hang outs and whatever. But venues were hardly an easy thing to swing and the larger community engulfing the smaller music community was hardly supportive of live music, skaters etc. To hear music, you had to pay for it. You had to literally GO TO THE RECORD STORE or GO TO THE SHOW. There was no internet and there was only word of mouth and some very hard working individuals who sacrificed all kinds of hardships so that Houston allowed any kind of option at all for the music scene in general. NOT JUST THE YOUTH of that era.
Am I old? Maybe. I am 35 years old. I did my time living on McKinney and Commerce Street before there were condos protected by iron gates. My friends were mostly older than me and a handful were younger. I never once thought to tell someone to get fucked because they were older and I was just trying to have fun. It wasn't the reality of the era, because contrary to what many scenesters in H town believe today, I think there was more unity then than there is now.
And we had fun, but it wasn't because having fun and just loving everybody was what made the scene function. We had fun because there was tension, and a sense of having something that was special and only ours. People weren't afraid to have an opinion about other musicians, because in the end- people respected each other. You didn't have to keep your bad thoughts to yourself. In fact, being honest was encouraged to the point of absurdity sometimes.
I don't participate in the music scene in Houston, because I don't have the time. I don't have the money. I have the time to go to work, and the money to barely get by.
I sit on my computer and listen to music from all over the planet just like every one else fortunate enough to do so. For some of us, okay ME, I don't have the luxury to hang out at Rudyards and pretend everything is great because at least there is people CREATING, and we shouldn't shit on them for creating.
Personally, I like seeing people invest time to give something to the community by way of art and music etc. That isn't the only way that you can give to your community though. You can give by being honest. You can give by being yourself.
I never understood the whole Jandek thing anyway. It reminds me of the movie Being There- which scores of people also thought was brilliant.
If I was a musician in Houston right now, I would wonder if I was really as great as everyone thought I was- if it wasn't politically correct to tell me I sucked.
I would take the hard truth over blissful support.. which is creepy.
I am tired. Goodbye.
I will admit that talking about how Houston was and is now in the music scene deserves more attention than what I gave it, and it wasn't my intention to further harden the line that separates the scene by talking about walking home in the snow uphill.
But things are different now. Very different. There are City sponsored skate parks and music venues everywhere.. and that isn't the way it always was. People were beaten and rights were violated for the fun spots that are enjoyed today.
I would be interested in REALLY knowing, what the current youth music scene in Houston really struggles with. Seriously. What are the issues? Is it cranky expats being critical? I honestly don't know, because like I said earlier I can't afford to participate on the level I did in the past for many reasons.
The thread-killer strikes again.
OK, admittedly I've been living under a rock for the last few...er, decades, but let me see if I have this story straight so far --
Jandek is some kind of crypto-Fripp originating from Houston who cultivated this international man of mystery deal, then he shows up at Rudz and plays a set of what one of my dorm bands might have done in the 80s, had we aspired to play funk, had a few bong hits, and found a bass player who could pop.
Well, to each their own. God knows I danced to a lot of bad funk back in the day, so I'm in no position to judge.
But I will add this; that even the best musicians sometimes fail or stray way out of what they are good at. Neil Young was responsible for both Rust Never Sleeps, and Trans, for example.
On the other hand if the guy was kind of a fraud all along, then that argument doesn't really hold. I haven't ever heard any of his stuff outside of this video, but if this video is representative.... uh... let's just say, I want my money back and I didn't even pay anything.
Here's how I see it.
As far as what Jandek brings to the table on a purely technical basis, I think the video is a reasonable representation of his known ability. That is to say, the guy can't play his way out of a paper bag.
I don't have a clue if this is actually true, but from his recordings (all we have save for his similar shows), it appears as though he is...
I'll put it this way - he is a non-traditional guitarist. That's fine with me, by the way.
I have no intrinsic problem with funk at all, in fact, I love the hell out of a ton of it. I think the way it is being handled in the video is generic bar funk at best and at worst an unforgivable musical sin.
If the young miss Mlee is being honest and not just making a badly formed point, then for her, this comes off as a sign of my no longer being valid due to my age. It's a ridiculous argument.
As a critic, and we are all critics of one sort or another, I drew my conclusions based on what I had before me combined with whatever it is that brings me to the point at which I decide to criticize.
This isn't quantifiable information. Jandek isn't performing math equations that I can prove are incorrect, he's playing music.
My opinions, presented in a strong, and perhaps even quite harsh tone, paint a picture more of the writer than the writing (methinks), and thereby leaves me the butt of what seems to me to be misguided anger.
That's okay, I asked for it.
Was the show cosmically bad?
Answer that for yourself.
And then when you're done, write a post for this blog. We welcome submissions.
Thanks for commenting, Sparrows, I miss your intelligence in this stuff. (Far superior to my own, I might add.)
Post a Comment